This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Nostalgia Cooked
November 17th, 2026
No. 21

IHOPS Destruction of the American Palate.

“Hands, please”

“The ridiculous way we have become entrenched in the same old same old of American breakfast, a cracker that was inspired by Welsh rarebit, and why we’ve been getting salt scammed for God knows how long, this week on Nostalgia Cooked.”

Coffee, then read on.

- Chef Tim

America is Weird About Breakfast

Spending time in both Europe and Asia, investigating different cultures and their approaches to food, has led me to develop some pretty hot opinions. This week, I want to discuss breakfast.

I used to think America had it made when it came to breakfast. In reality, I think I was addicted to sugar and couldn't see the forest for the trees. Froot Loops, Fruity Pebbles, Rooty Tooty Fresh 'N Fruity, Honey Smacks. The list goes on. So much of what we consider breakfast revolves around refined starches, sugar and fatty meats. We do a horrible job of setting ourselves up to actually feel good for the rest of the day. Even our coffee, which on its own contains virtually no calories, has become a vehicle for flavored syrups, whipped cream and enough sugar to rival a slice of chocolate cake.

Meanwhile, in Japan, you can begin your morning with grilled fish, rice, seaweed, pickled vegetables or a delicate steamed egg custard. In China, you might have a bowl of savory rice porridge with ginger and pork, or a bowl of wonton soup. In Germany, bread, cheese and cured meats are perfectly acceptable at eight in the morning. These cultures have a much more fluid relationship with the ingredients they consume throughout the day. Americans, on the other hand, have spent the better part of the last 80 years living in some sugar-crazed, syrup-drenched, psychotic pancake dream.

What fascinates me is that we already enjoy many of the foods these countries eat for breakfast. We just refuse to eat them before noon. A piece of grilled salmon sounds delicious for dinner, but put it in front of someone at seven in the morning and suddenly you've lost your mind. Somehow, covering a stack of chocolate chip pancakes with maple syrup is the more reasonable thing to do.

As a chef, I find it particularly strange that vegetables have such a limited presence on the American breakfast table. We might incorporate some spinach into an omelette or serve a few slices of horrible tomato still on the vine with our 3 egg omelette , but rarely do we prepare vegetables with the same enthusiasm that we do for dinner. Imagine beginning your morning with roasted mushrooms, buttered cabbage or a bowl of chicken broth with seasonal vegetables.

I also wonder how much of our palate is shaped by what we eat for breakfast as children. If you spend the first decade of your life eating something sweet every morning, how receptive are you going to be to a bowl of miso soup or a piece of grilled fish? We spend so much time discussing how to get American children to eat vegetables, yet we've practically eliminated an entire meal from the day in which they might encounter them.

I happen to think that American breakfast is still one of the great pleasures of our cuisine. There are few things I enjoy more than a properly cooked plate of eggs, crispy hash browns and sausage. I wonder why we have been so slow to expand upon it.

Over the last few years, I've been determined as a chef to figure this out. How do we make savory breakfasts as desirable to Americans as a stack of pancakes? Is there any way to snap America out of it? Do we still have a chance of reversing course after decades of slowly dripping sugar into our veins?

Cheez-itz grow on trees.

Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Subscribe:

Line Up - The Cheez-It

Before service, the whole crew huddles up and someone tells the story behind the food. Pull up a crate, you’re on the line tonight.

I was walking around the 2026 Waterfowl Festival in Easton, Maryland this past weekend and was reminded of the love I once felt for this childhood snack. I present to you the history and curiosities of one of America’s greatest snacks.

The Cheez-It has been a part of the American diet for over a century. It predates the American introduction of Goldfish crackers by forty-one years. For a product that has undergone relatively few changes since its invention, I was curious about where it came from and how it became so popular.

Although the Cheez-It wasn't invented until 1921, the company responsible for it can trace its origins back to a nineteenth-century physician named William W. Wolf. Wolf developed a hard butter cracker for his patients in Dayton, Ohio. Following his death in 1897, John Green purchased his bakery and established the Green & Green Company with his son Weston. Twenty-four years later, the company introduced an entirely different cracker that would become one of America's most recognizable snack foods.

The original Cheez-It was advertised as a baked rarebit. Welsh rarebit is a British dish of melted cheese served over toast, often prepared with beer and mustard. The cheese browns under the broiler, developing the concentrated flavor of cooked cheese that we associate with the cracker. Raise your hand if you’ve eaten a Welsh rarebit before.

By 1929, Green & Green was distributing its products nationwide, and in 1932, the company was purchased by the Loose-Wiles Biscuit Company, which would later become Sunshine Biscuits. The availability of inexpensive packaged foods helped change the way Americans ate between meals throughout the twentieth century, as we’ve previously discussed in other newsletters. Cheez-Its were particularly well suited to this change because they were affordable and could be stored in the cupboard for months.

The original packaging was green and white, a departure from the red box we recognize today. Sunshine Biscuits eventually adopted the familiar red packaging and continued manufacturing the crackers for decades. Keebler purchased Sunshine in 1996, and Kellogg acquired Keebler in 2001. In 2020 alone, Americans purchased more than 400 million packages of Cheez-Its.

From a culinary standpoint, the Cheez-It is a well-made cracker. The Original variety uses real cheese produced from skim milk, and the dough undergoes fermentation before being rolled out and baked. The little hole in the center is a technique called docking, which we use in professional kitchens to prevent pastry from puffing up excessively in the oven. Paprika and annatto contribute to the cracker's recognizable orange color.

I think a considerable amount of the nostalgia surrounding Cheez-Its comes from their association with the American school lunch. Before individually packaged snacks became so commonplace, parents would portion crackers from a larger box into little plastic sandwich bags. Cheez-Its were inexpensive enough to feed an entire family throughout the week and required no refrigeration. Their popularity extended well beyond school cafeterias, particularly as Americans began consuming more packaged snacks while watching television.

In 2002, the company introduced its “Get Your Own Box” advertising campaign, which played on the idea that people were reluctant to share their Cheez-Its. The company has since expanded into dozens of varieties, including White Cheddar, Hot & Spicy and Extra Toasty. The latter was introduced in 2015 after years of customers requesting an entire box of the darker crackers that occasionally appeared in regular packages.

In 2019, Cheez-It partnered with House Wine to sell a combination package of boxed wine and cheese crackers. In 2024, Taco Bell introduced a Crunchwrap containing a Cheez-It sixteen times the size of the original cracker. Despite these collaborations and the growing number of flavors, Original Cheez-Its remain the foundation of the brand more than a hundred years after their introduction. Well done.

Top Tip

❝

Three places with three different breakfasts you can try in the DMV.

  1. Japanese - Perry’s. Offers full Japanese Brunch on the weekends.

  2. Chinese - Joy Luck Pot. Full traditional chinese breakfast everyday from 10:30 AM.

  3. Turkish - Caspian Crust. The sultan’s feast for two is traditional Turkish Breakfast

3 Things Worth Your Time

  • An article: Maldon Sea Salt is under fire this week after it was reported that they also import German rock salt. Buy this instead.

  • A recipe: A plague of Little Debbie promotional videos hit my feed this week. Apparently people make dip out of BLENDED CHRISTMAS TREE CAKES….

  • A place: An old cook of mine, recently visited and is doing great. Here’s the restaurant he’s currently working at.

Potato’s Pairing

I’d go with brut Cava. It’s dry and bright, with green apple and a little toast that picks up the browned edges of a Cheez-It. The bubbles cut through the richness of the cheddar, and the salt makes you want another sip.

I’ll be under the couch conducting a separate pairing with whatever you drop.

❝

Buell's Booth
Slide in, grab a seat. Every week, one question and one comment straight from the counter. Feel free to shoot me questions anytime!

“No Colman’s?”

It may have been an oversight. It may have been discrimination. But for some reason, on our mustard tasting table, Colman’s didn’t even get to the bench. An investigation is ongoing and we will report back when we have the latest updates.

“I do have a funny mustard story for you...a couple years back me and my hubby went to Paris and took an excursion to the famous and fabulous La Grande Epicerie gourmet market. What a perfect place to pick up some souvenirs for our family or so I thought.  I bought among other goodies, a very pricey and very fancy tube of French "moutarde" which my dingbat mother-in-law thought was HAND CREAM. She had literally been slathering it all over her hands and arms like she was basting a dang pork roast.”

The best reader story I’ve received yet. Thank you to this loyal reader, and I hope someone else finds this as funny as I do.

The Nostalgia Table

The second Monday of every month · 7 o’clock · Eight seats. Location shared by post the week of. Subscribers receive first word. Write for a seat